Dispelling Myths About Purgatory

Dispelling Myths About Purgatory

Many misunderstandings exist about Purgatory, particularly among non-Catholics, and even some Catholics. Below, we address common myths and provide solid explanations rooted in Scripture and Tradition, highlighting how Purgatory reflects God's justice and mercy. We also offer rebuttals to typical Protestant objections, ensuring a deeper understanding of this doctrine.

For more information on understanding what happens after we die, click here.

Myth 1: Purgatory Is a "Second Chance" for the Damned

Some believe that Purgatory gives sinners a "second chance" after death, where those condemned to hell might somehow earn their way into heaven. This is entirely false.

• The Catholic teaching: Purgatory is only for those who have died in a state of grace (i.e., those who are ultimately destined for heaven). It is not for souls in a state of mortal sin or for those in hell (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1030-1031). Purgatory is a process of purification for those who have already been judged worthy of heaven but must undergo purification before entering into God's presence.

• Biblical foundation: 1 Corinthians 3:15 speaks of a man being "saved, but only as through fire." This passage refers to a process where a person's works are tested by fire after death. This does not suggest a "second chance" for the damned but indicates that even those destined for salvation may require purification.

• Counter to Protestant objection: Some Protestants assert that since Christ's death was sufficient to forgive sins (and it was), there is no need for Purgatory. However, Catholics do not dispute that Christ’s sacrifice on the cross atones for sin. The issue addressed by Purgatory is not forgiveness, but purification of the temporal effects of sin. Even when forgiven, sin leaves behind consequences, both in this world and the next, that must be purified (CCC 1472). The notion of cleansing the soul post-mortem is not contrary to Christ’s sacrifice but a participation in the grace Christ offers.

Myth 2: Purgatory Is Not Biblical

A common objection is that Purgatory is "unbiblical" because the word "Purgatory" does not appear in the Bible. However, the concept of Purgatory is strongly supported by both Scripture and Tradition.

• Biblical references: Although the term "Purgatory" itself is not in Scripture (similar to the term "Trinity"), the Bible supports the idea of purification after death:

  • 2 Maccabees 12:44-46 praises the act of praying for the dead that they might be released from sin: "For if he were not expecting that those who had fallen would rise again, it would have been superfluous and foolish to pray for the dead." Though Protestants reject this book, it was accepted by Christians for over 1,500 years and remains part of the Catholic canon.

  • Matthew 12:32—Jesus speaks of sins that will not be forgiven "either in this age or in the age to come," suggesting that some sins can be forgiven after death.

  • 1 Peter 1:7 refers to the purification of faith as being "tested by fire" to purify it, which can be understood as a process that continues after death.

  • 1 Corinthians 3:12-15 describes a person’s works being tested by fire after death, where some are purified in the fire while the person is saved.

• Tradition: The early Church Fathers, including St. Augustine and St. Gregory the Great, taught about Purgatory. For example, St. Augustine wrote, “Temporal punishments are suffered by some in this life only, by others after death, by others both here and there; but all of them before that last and strictest judgment” (City of God, Book XXI, Chapter 13). Tradition has always recognized the need to purify the soul before entering the full presence of God.

• Counter to Protestant objection: Protestants often reject 2 Maccabees as part of their canon, but this rejection came 1,500 years after Christ. Martin Luther removed it from the Protestant Bible because it contradicted his theology. The early Church accepted 2 Maccabees, and prayers for the dead were a part of Christian practice long before the Protestant Reformation. Moreover, the concept of Purgatory is supported by the Bible, even if not explicitly named.

Myth 3: Christ’s Sacrifice Was Sufficient—No Need for Purgatory

One of the strongest Protestant arguments is that since Christ’s sacrifice was sufficient for the forgiveness of all sins, the concept of Purgatory undermines this sacrifice. However, this reflects a misunderstanding of Purgatory's purpose.

• The Catholic understanding: Purgatory does not detract from Christ's sacrifice. Instead, it is an application of the merits of Christ’s sacrifice for the purification of the soul. While Christ's death on the cross was indeed sufficient to forgive sins, Purgatory deals with the temporal consequences of sin, not its guilt. Even after sin is forgiven, its temporal effects remain and require purification. This concept of temporal punishment is seen throughout the Bible: King David, although forgiven by God for his sin with Bathsheba, still endured the consequences of that sin (2 Samuel 12:13-14).

• Scripture and logic: When we sin, we offend both God and neighbor. Through the sacrament of Confession, we are reconciled with God, but the damage done to our neighbor and ourselves must still be repaired. This is similar to someone who breaks a window and is forgiven by the homeowner but must still repair the window. Similarly, after our sins are forgiven, we may still need purification to enter into the full glory of God.

• Counter to Protestant objection: Protestant theology tends to reject any notion of "works" after death, but Purgatory does not contradict grace—it is entirely based on it. Purgatory applies Christ’s grace to the soul in a final purification. Christ's redemptive work continues in Purgatory, as it is through His merits that souls are purified.

Myth 4: Purgatory Is a Catholic Invention

Some claim that the doctrine of Purgatory was invented by the Catholic Church in the Middle Ages to instill fear or raise money (via indulgences). This is historically inaccurate.

• Early Church Fathers and Councils: Long before the Middle Ages, the Church Fathers affirmed the existence of Purgatory. St. Cyprian (3rd century) wrote about the purifying fire of the next life. St. Augustine (4th century) prayed for the dead and instructed others to do the same. The Council of Carthage (394) and the Second Council of Lyons (1274) both affirmed the existence of Purgatory.

• Constant Tradition: Purgatory has always been part of the Church’s understanding of the afterlife. The misconception that it was "invented" in the Middle Ages stems from confusion over indulgences, which are often misunderstood as "buying forgiveness" (a practice condemned by the Church). In reality, indulgences are means by which the Church, through the authority of Christ, applies the merits of His death and resurrection to remit the temporal punishment due to sin.

• Counter to Protestant objection: The Protestant claim that Purgatory was a later invention ignores centuries of Christian Tradition, including the writings of numerous early Church Fathers who clearly referenced prayers for the dead and purification after death. It also overlooks the councils that affirmed this doctrine, long before the Reformation.

Myth 5: Purgatory Is a "Catholic Only" Belief

While it is true that the majority of Protestant denominations reject Purgatory, many of the founding leaders of Protestantism still held to a form of post-death purification.

• Lutheran and Anglican Views: Martin Luther, the founder of Lutheranism, spoke about the possibility of post-death purification and prayers for the dead, although he rejected the formal teaching of Purgatory. The Anglican Church, in its early years, retained prayers for the dead, acknowledging that some form of purification might be necessary. Even John Wesley, the founder of Methodism, believed that the souls of the dead might experience a period of cleansing.

• Counter to Protestant objection: While many modern Protestants reject the idea of Purgatory, the roots of this doctrine can be found in the Bible, Church Fathers, and even early Protestant traditions. Rejecting Purgatory is a relatively recent development in Christian history, and it is rooted in misunderstandings of Scripture and Tradition.

Conclusion

Purgatory is not a "second chance" or an "unbiblical" invention, but a profound expression of God's mercy and justice. It allows souls who have died in His grace but are not yet fully purified to be cleansed and enter into the beatific vision. Scripture supports the notion of post-death purification, and the Church, from its earliest days, has upheld this doctrine. Far from undermining Christ's sacrifice, Purgatory applies the merits of His passion for the purification of the soul, enabling us to enter into the fullness of God's presence.

By praying for the souls in Purgatory, we participate in a great act of charity, helping them to reach heaven, and in turn, they will intercede for us when they enter into God’s presence. Let us remember their needs and continue to offer our prayers and sacrifices for them.